I've seen the criticism: Teachers pay Teachers offers nothing but a bunch of mindless worksheets that waste students' time and do nothing to advance learning. Yes, teachers can find resources like this on TpT. However, if they search wisely, they will find many valuable resources that not only save them time but also lead to meaningful learning for their students. It is not hard to find quality resources on Teachers Pay Teachers, and this post will help you learn how to distinguish the good from the bad.
Finding great resources on TpT is really no different than any time you go searching online. Looking for a new sweater? You can end up with something that looked oh-so-cute on your phone, but when it arrives on your doorstep, it's poorly made, doesn't fit well, and a seam tears after one wearing. Or, you can go to trusted sites, carefully read the details & reviews, and end up with a go-to comfy sweater that becomes your all-time favorite.
This works the same on TpT. With a careful search, teachers will find many resources that provide quality learning for students. These lessons are research-based, classroom-tested, and designed to scaffold the skills that students need. The activities are far from mindless and can add to the engagement and learning in a teacher's classroom. They can also lead to less work in the evenings and weekends.
So...how do you get what you need?
Use the right words in the search bar
First, like any research, it requires quality terms in the search bar. If a teacher types "Writing Lessons," they will get thousands of hits and will have to scroll through piles of irrelevant resources to find something good.
So, be as specific as you can while searching. First, toggle the correct grade & subject so you aren't getting activities for K-2 when you need something for high school. Then, instead of searching for "writing lessons," search for the specific lessons you need: "teaching focus and organization" or "showing not telling lessons." If you are looking for a specific type of writing, add that in too: "literary analysis embedding quotations," or "research skills paraphrasing MLA." Do you want to help your students improve their ability to analyze text? Try "active reading literary analysis" or "elements of fiction mini-lessons."
These very specific terms will give you a better chance of downloading something that really works for you and your students.
Also, when you type in the search bar, other relevant ideas will be provided by TpT, so look below it to see if one of those suggestions fits. Once you've narrowed your search, you'll have an easier time finding what you need.
Look closely at the thumbnails and the previews
We all know that you can not always judge a book by its cover. However, the thumbnails and preview are the first clues to a quality resource. Check out the cover and then take the time to look through the preview provided by the seller. If it's done well, that's the first sign that you're getting a quality lesson or activity.
Secondly, a good preview will show you how can use the resource with your students. If it's just a bunch of pretty worksheets with little substance - that's what you're getting. Instead, look for previews that clearly explain exactly what you and your students will be able to do with the resource.
Click here to see the preview for my Embedding & Citing Quotations resource as an example.
Read the resource details and description
I've gotten reviews where the teacher comments that the resource was not appropriate for their grade level when the resource was never meant for, let's say, a grade four SPED class. It was labeled for grade nine, but they bought it anyway and were disappointed it didn't fit. So take the time to read the bullets that state grade and subject, and then move on to the description.
Reading the description will show you if the resource suits your needs, AND it will also give you some insight into the quality of the resource you are getting. If the seller has taken the time to provide lots of detail about the ways you can use their resource, chances are you will find detail and rigor in the download too.
Search "Most Recent" as well as "Best Sellers"
Quality TpT resources focus on student learning
I will admit that the criticism I see hits hard sometimes because I know how much effort I put into creating resources that help students engage with meaningful learning. Blanket (and false) statements make teachers feel bad about using TpT and ignore the fact that many of us are working hard to create good stuff.
My resources are based on three decades of watching how students learn AND three decades of studying just what engages them. From my first day as a teacher, I was a voracious learner too, noting what worked and what didn't. I read the research. I tweaked my lessons time and again until I was happy. I started creating lessons for TpT when I'd already been at this game for twenty years, and all of my learning has gone into my resources.
So, when you get a lesson from ROOM 213 (or any of my friends here in the Coffee Shop), you are getting one that is carefully crafted to engage students in meaningful learning. Instead of busy work, you get:
- Detailed lesson plans that scaffold the learning process
- Slideshows that teachers can use to guide instruction, discussion, & activities
- Activities & exercises designed to give students practice building the targeted skills
- Handouts (you might even call them worksheets - ones that aren't mindless)
- Opportunities for collaboration & movement
- When appropriate, assessment tools and classroom management tips
That, my friends, is far from a mindless worksheet - so don't believe the blanket statements some people make about TpT resources because you will find many sellers who offer you quality resources to use with students.
I wholeheartedly believe TpT can provide a lifeline for teachers who are overworked and under-resourced. It can give those who are just too tired to come up with something themselves a lesson that will get students excited about learning. And it can provide s inspiration for teachers who are just looking for something new to try. Just as I look for inspiration online when I want to redecorate, a teacher can find lots of creative inspiration from fellow teachers online too.
So, when you go on TpT in search of something for your students, don't just go for something that looks all pretty and flashy. Be discerning: read the details and look at the previews. You may just get an all-time favorite.
My colleagues here at the Coffee Shop also offer resources that go way beyond busy work. Check these out:
Tracee Orman - Guided Poetry Presentation
Presto Plans - Figurative Language Escape Room Review
The Classroom Sparrow - Essay Writing Scavenger Hunt